Germany's competition authority questions PayPal's surcharge ban in a preliminary assessment
German webshop with PayPal? A preliminary assessment says PayPal's extra-fee ban could restrict competition. It is not a final decision, so don't add a fee yet.
You run a German webshop with PayPal at checkout, and a headline makes it sound as if you can finally charge customers extra for paying with PayPal. On 11 November the Bundeskartellamt, Germany's competition authority, told PayPal in a preliminary assessment that its ban on those extra fees could restrict competition, and its press release says: "This does not constitute a final decision." The ban stays in PayPal's terms, and PayPal is entitled to end the business relationship with merchants who breach it.
The useful question for your shop is what PayPal costs you, and what to do with that number while the rule stands.
What the preliminary assessment says
"According to the Bundeskartellamt's preliminary assessment, this prohibition could restrict competition between various payment services and violate competition law." In that preliminary view, the authority sees a possible violation of the bans on anti-competitive agreements and on abusive practices. PayPal now has the opportunity to comment.
Reuters Legal reported the same preliminary concern on 11 November, writing that the ban "may hinder competition and possibly violate the law."
The proceeding dates back to 23 January 2023, when the authority opened it. It is about PayPal's terms in German online retail.
Why the authority is concerned
The authority's current findings say "PayPal charges above-average fees compared to other payment methods." Merchant fees vary by payment method, sometimes considerably, and larger merchants negotiate theirs individually.
Because the ban stops shops passing those costs directly to PayPal users, merchants must spread them across all their customers through their prices. A shopper who never uses PayPal still helps pay for it.
PayPal users, the authority adds, get no cost transparency and so no incentive to choose a cheaper way to pay.
What German law allows
The authority says it "would in principle be allowed under German law to charge customers for paying with PayPal, provided in particular that the charges do not exceed the actual costs incurred by the merchant." Extra charges are excluded by law for consumer credit cards, SEPA transfers and direct debits.
Your contract is the catch. PayPal's terms have prohibited these charges since 2018, and according to the present state of the investigations, PayPal has been enforcing that rule. The authority is also considering making PayPal give up economic benefits obtained through the possible infringement. It states no amount, fine, fee level or effective date.
What this means for your business
Back to your webshop with PayPal at checkout. We think this is a warning shot at PayPal and no green light for you. The rule that bans the fee is still in your contract, and breaching it can cost you PayPal as a way to get paid.
We suggest three steps this month:
- Pull your recent payment reports and work out what PayPal costs you per order next to your other methods.
- Keep your PayPal checkout free of any extra fee while the ban remains in PayPal's terms.
- File that cost figure, so you know what accepting PayPal really costs your shop.
This article is guidance, not legal advice, and it covers Germany and PayPal only.
For now, your best tool is a spreadsheet with your real PayPal costs in it.
Sources
- Bundeskartellamt, press release on its preliminary assessment of PayPal's surcharge rules (published 11 November 2026).
- Reuters Legal on X, post of 11 November 2026.
This article was researched, written and fact-checked by MasterNodeAI's AI newsroom agents.
Related: Security & Regulation desk
MasterNodeAI is building an AI interface that helps small and medium business owners run their business. Join the waitlist and we will let you know when you can try it.